Skip to Main Content

Documenting OER Efforts


A critical part of sustaining Open Educational Resources (OER) in higher education is recognizing the contributions by instructors who locate, identify, improve, and create materials as part of their professional work. In order to aid this effort, Driving OER Sustainability for Student Success (DOERS3) has developed an adaptable advisory model to help guide faculty as they attempt to include their OER work in their tenure and promotion portfolios. This model is in no way exhaustive and will likely be most useful as a way for faculty to start thinking about how to best highlight and describe their OER work into their local P&T guidelines.


Each P&T process is based on one’s departmental guidelines. Although individual departments may differ from this matrix in its use of these categories, most variations of tenure and promotion guidelines can be adapted to teaching, research, and service.


While few institutions have recognized open educational practices as deliverables toward tenure and promotion, faculty, in documenting their OER work in their portfolios, should characterize their work using terms that aid their colleagues in understanding their contribution.


For each contribution, we have suggested whether the contribution could apply to those three categories, and in some cases, we have marked multiple categories--which is most relevant will depend upon the context. In addition, the matrix includes examples of how faculty might think strategically about where their open education contributions would be valued most and how best to frame those contributions. Where it is applicable, we have added brief examples of language from sample dossiers to demonstrate what this type of evidence might look like.

Adopt

Contribution Evidence Research Teaching Service
Use OER in a class or classes For participants in the OER Initiative here at UNF, evidence used in the P/T dossier might include the narrative summarizing the challenges and accomplishments of their experiences finding and using OER materials, its impact on teaching, impact on students, and lessons learned.

Survey and gather data on how the use of an OER in class affected student learning. A similar study was conducted in British Columbia as well as in the United States via the Open Education Research Group.
  Yes  
Use Open Access research article Provide evidence of the Open Access Journal Articles that were used in course outline.   Yes  
To view an example of a dossier integrating the adoption and use of existing OER, see example 1.


Adapt

Contribution Evidence Research Teaching Service
Revise others’ OER to be more relevant to student needs Survey students in class to learn more about the impact the revised materials have had on their learning. A similar study was conducted in British Columbia.   Yes Yes
Revise or remix OER to be in alignment with course learning outcomes Provide evidence on what was revised or remixed to best suit the course learning outcomes. Survey students in class to learn about the impact the revised materials had on their learning.   Yes  


Create

Contribution Evidence Research Teaching Service
Make new OER When creating OER, make it available to peers for their review. Document their reviews and include those reviews in your dossier. The following is a common rubric used to review Open Textbooks. Yes Yes  
To view an example of a dossier integrating the adoption and use of existing OER, see example 2.


Improve Learning

Contribution Evidence Research Teaching Service
Improve student outcomes To best understand the improvement of student outcomes, increased student engagement, innovation, and reduction in cost- survey students in your course. Review the survey and questions conducted in “A multi-institutional study of the impact of open textbook adoption on the learning outcomes of post-secondary students”.   Yes  
Innovation   Yes  
Increasing student engagement   Yes  
Reduce material costs to students   Yes  


Community

Contribution Evidence Research Teaching Service
Mentoring others in OER Provide recommendation letters from mentorships and via the mentee.     Yes
OER leadership (change culture, policy change, lead an initiative) Provide a list of committees and specific actions you took related to OER and committee work. For tasks led, describe the initiative, provide evidence of change, and seek references and recommendation on the work completed.     Yes
Disseminate knowledge about OER Provide list of workshops, webinars, presentations related to OER and OE advocacy.     Yes
Peer review existing OER Provide citations of the reviews conducted.   Yes Yes


Research

Contribution Evidence Research Teaching Service
Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SOTL) about OER Provide citations and links to work completed related to SOTL and OER. Yes Yes  
Conference Presentations Provide citations, links, recordings, and slides of the work done to disseminate OER knowledge. Yes   Yes
Grant writing Provide excerpts from grant proposals, including budgetary asks and narrative as to how the grant will benefit the department and/or institution. Yes   Yes