| I. |
Call to Order |
| |
President Kathleen Cohen called the meeting to order
at 12:17 p.m. |
| |
|
| II. |
Approval of Minutes
- October 4, 2001 |
| |
The minutes of the October 4, 2001 meeting were approved
as distributed on the Web. |
| |
|
| III. |
Announcements |
| |
|
| |
President Cohen reminded faculty members that tomorrow
is the last day of the faculty/staff fund drive.
Hazel Higgins introduced the new Follett Bookstore
manager, Jeremy Johnson. Mr. Johnson came to UNF from Rollins College
and was previously employed at Florida State University for five
years. He discussed the transition taking place at the bookstore.
Mr. Johnson promised that textbooks would be delivered overnight
in emergencies and that everything will be fully operational for
the spring term. Mr. Johnson said he plans for the bookstore to
be a highly visible part of the campus and immediately responsive.
In closing, he reminded faculty that cap and gown rentals are due
by Wednesday.
|
| |
|
| IV. |
Standing Committee
Reports |
| |
|
| |
Academic
Programs Committee - Len
Roberson |
| |
No report. The committee will meet November 8 from
10:00 - noon in FAMA.
|
| |
|
| |
Academic
Standards Committee - Pali
Sen |
| |
The committee has two items on today's agenda. Members
met October 4 and October 25. The next meeting is scheduled for
November 5 at 10:00 a.m. in FAMA.
|
| |
|
| |
Academic
Technology and Support Services Committee -
Bruce
Kavan |
| |
No report. |
| |
|
| |
Adjunct
Affairs Committee - Ted Stumm |
| |
No report. |
| |
|
| |
Budget
Advisory Committee - Homer Bates |
| |
No report. The committee is still attempting to
arrange a meeting with President Hopkins. They could possibly meet
in the middle of November.
|
| |
|
| |
Faculty
Affairs Committee - Judy Solano |
| |
The committee has one information item in today's
packet. It concerns the possibility of adopting the College of Business
Administration's questions designed to supplement the SUSSAI. An
open hearing is scheduled for November 9 at noon in the College
of Business, room 1020. Dr. Solano told members if they have questions
and cannot attend the meeting, they should email either her or Bill
Wilson.
The committee will meet Thursday, November 8 at
12:15 in the library.
|
| |
|
| |
Faculty
Enhancement Committee - Cynthia Scott |
| |
No report.
|
| |
|
| |
Governmental
Relations Committee - Dan Whitehead |
| |
The committee met October 19. Janet Owen met with
the group. The committee will meet again November 16. |
| |
|
| |
Nominations
and Elections Committee - Diane Tanner |
| |
An election for members of the Nominations and Elections
Committee was held today. There were no nominations from the floor
the slate was elected by acclamation. |
| |
|
| |
Promotion
and Tenure Committee - Faiz Al-Rubaee |
| |
No report.
|
| |
|
| |
Research
Committee - Cheryl Van Deusen |
| |
The committee met October 23 regarding summer research
grants. Selection results were forwarded to the Department of Academic
Affairs.
|
| |
|
| |
Strategic
Planning Committee - Matthew Corrigan
for Gary Fane |
| |
No report. |
| |
|
| |
Executive
Committee - Kathleen Cohen for Cheryl Frohlich |
| |
The next meeting will be November 19 at 12:15 in
FAMA. |
| |
|
| V. |
Special Reports |
| |
|
| |
President
Anne Hopkins |
| |
Dr. Hopkins wanted to discuss some general budget
issues. She noted that she had frozen some budget items in anticipation
of the legislature's probable cuts. She wanted to make people understand
that even though the reports are that the budget cuts will not be
as bad as anticipated, they are still very substantial. The governor
will use some of the state's rainy day funds, but if he spends too
much now there will not be any for next year, and he needs to be
prepared if there is a disaster. Estimates are that the economy
will not make a fast recovery. Dr. Hopkins said she has still not
held back enough money to fund this year and she expects there may
be more cuts by the legislature later in the year. She said she
must try to plan for that. She does not want to lay people off and
she noted that pay raises did not get tampered with. Those UNF employees
with salaries over $90,000 who are not part of the bargaining unit
will not get raises this year. She had a question about travel restrictions
and discussed why the vice president must approve any travel. As
soon as she knows what the budget will be she will set targets for
each division.
Dr. Hopkins said this is a chance for the university
to change and improve. She wants to use this opportunity to rethink
the way we do things. She is willing to accept any suggestions.
She will look at every idea.
The following questions for David Kline and Anne
Hopkins were asked by Judy Solano.
On behalf of the faculty of the University of North
Florida, the Faculty Affairs Committee wishes to ask some questions
arising out of the recent purge of adjunct faculty on the basis
of insufficient qualifications. Our questions are based on the following
observations and experiences of our members.
| a. |
That some adjunct faculty who were
NOT initially identified by the SACS review team as being unqualified
were nonetheless purged by the Office of Academic Affairs in
what appears to have been a far more sweeping application of
narrowly interpreted SACS criteria; |
| |
|
| b. |
That some adjunct faculty who were
deemed to be unqualified hold the same terminal degrees or other
qualifications as permanent full-time faculty at UNF; |
| |
|
| c. |
That some department chairs have
been told new adjunct hires will have to possess the same qualifications
as regular permanent faculty hires, and go through the same
rigorous review processes; |
| |
|
| d. |
That the process by which the recent
purge of adjuncts was carried out completely removed the determination
of appropriate qualifications for faculty OUT of the hands of
faculty at the departmental level. |
| |
|
| Based
on these observations and experiences, we ask the following
questions: |
| |
|
| 1. |
Are the facts as we understand
them to be correct? If not, will you provide the factual information
we need to correct our misunderstandings? |
| |
|
| 2. |
If the facts above are correct,
how does the Office of Academic Affairs propose to locate and
hire adjunct faculty who possess terminal degrees in specific
disciplines, along with respectable research/publication records,
and who are willing to teach mostly basic or highly specialized
courses at minimal compensations levels without benefits? |
| |
|
| 3. |
If no such qualified adjuncts are
available for some disciplines, will those departments be permitted
to hire more regular permanent faculty in order to meet the
demand for courses? |
| |
|
| 4. |
Will the hiring process for adjuncts
now become comparable to the lengthy and expensive hiring process
for regular faculty? |
| |
|
| 5. |
How will the hiring process for
both regular and adjunct faculty be handled now in those fields
which are traditionally multi-disciplinary or relatively young,
in which the composition of the professorate presently spans
a wide range of fields and in which faculty often hold terminal
degrees outside a specific disciplinary name? |
| |
|
| 6. |
At what point can department faculty
and chairs expect to reclaim jurisdiction over the process of
determining appropriate qualifications for their faculty? |
| |
|
Dr. Hopkins responded to the first questions about
the purge of adjunct faculty. She did not think the firings should
be characterized as a purge. She tried to explain how and why the
firings occurred. Dr. Hopkins took responsibility for the firings.
She said SACS expects only her to be in charge, so she stepped in
and she and David Kline read every adjunct file. The two of them
decided who was qualified and who was not.
She noted that SACS itself does not approve anybody
and never has. She explained that when SACS visitors first come,
they can look at anything they want. They have boxes of files at
their disposal and they select files randomly. They identified seven
things that troubled them. The university quickly reduced that down
to one adjunct faculty. Dr. Hopkins discussed how SACS representatives
imply who is acceptable. In her close contact with them, she feels
she knows what they expect. She noted that the university has hired
many people over its 29 years and some might not have met all requirements.
Dr. Hopkins said all chairs have now been told
that adjuncts must meet the same requirements as regular hires.
Minimum degree requirements will be met for all new adjunct hires.
Dr. Solano asked how the university will find people
in the community who meet adjunct requirements? What will happen
if they can't be found? Will departments who need them be able to
hire regular permanent faculty?
Dr. Hopkins responded that she must figure out
the budget first. She does not know yet how it will be handled.
She is thinking of ideas. This might be an opportunity for regular
faculty to get an overload with more pay. Qualified adjuncts
might get up to nine hours teaching load. She needs help locating
people. She wants to get them from other universities that are within
driving distance. David Kline is trying to look at release time.
There will be ads in newspapers. Dr. Hopkins said people in the
community know that the university is having trouble and are calling
in to say they have advanced degrees. She said that UNF must end
up with a fully qualified adjunct faculty.
|
| |
|
| |
Legislative
Liaison Report - Janet Owen |
| |
Janet Own reported on the budget bill. She said
negotiations were ongoing until the last minute. The Senate bill
is not ready and the Governor could veto the whole thing or he could
use the line item veto. She mentioned several highlights of the
special session.
|
| |
|
| |
United
Faculty of Florida - Elinor Scheirer |
| |
Dr. Scheirer commented that sometimes she is asked
"what does the union do for me." She noted that this year's
pay raises were protected. In 1992 they were not. Once a pay raise
is negotiated, it cannot be rescinded.
Dr. Scheirer reported on the senate meeting she
attended October 22 - 24. The bargaining council of UFF was instructed
by the senate to go to impasse. Bargaining negotiations scheduled
for October and November have been postponed. The University of
Florida has been organizing and preparing for the possibility of
local bargaining.
The UFF meeting on November 14 is open to all unit
members. On Friday, November16, there will be a grievance training
workshop.
|
| |
|
| VI. |
Question and Answer
Period |
| |
Scott Hochwald noted that students who are called
to active duty since the act of terrorism on September 11 are able
to get tuition refunds. He wondered if, in general, there is a way
for students to get refunds for courses at any time. He asked how
the process worked.
Dr. Hopkins responded that state policy permits
refunds to people who are called to active duty. Kim Luther said
students go to Student Affairs to get paperwork. The university
has had three students receive refunds.
Dr. Hochwald asked if a student can get money back
for any other reasons? Could a faculty member excuse a student from
a class and tell him to withdraw and get his money back? Dr. Hopkins
responded that no, they could not, that university policies did
not allow that.
Dr. Hochwald asked where are the policies that
answer these questions?
Dr. Hopkins responded that they are in the graduate
and undergraduate catalog.
Royal Van Horn said the question about faculty
members excusing a student from class and telling him to ask for
a refund was not answered adequately. A written question will be
sent.
|
| |
|
| VII. |
Legislative Items |
| |
Item #1 - FA 01-27: Submitted by the Academic
Standards Committee
Non-UNF course work may not be included on UNF
transcripts.
Pali Sen moved the item. Chris Rasche asked for clarification of
one minor item. Kim Luther responded to the question.
The item passed.
Item #2 - FA 01-28: Submitted by the Academic
Standards Committee
Addition of WA and WX - Administrative Withdrawal
Grades
Pali Sen moved the item.
Chris Rasche asked for clarification of the phrasing "necessitated
by university requirements." She asked under what conditions
a student would get a WA or WX? Pali Sen responded that the Association
passed items last year that were based on administrative withdrawal
policies. She indicated that the WA and WX are just parallel grades
like WF and WP.
Kathy Brown said she was curious about the rationale
that said the language broadens the range of options available to
a faculty member. If this is an administrative action, how could
the faculty have more options? Pali Sen responded that the intention
is if an administrator comes back and asks what a grade should be,
the faculty member has some choice. Kim Luther clarified several
other points.
The item passed.
President Cohen directed attendees' attention to the information
items in the agenda packet. She also reminded members about the
open hearing concerning the supplemental questions for the SUSSAI
form.
|
| |
|
| VIII. |
Adjournment |
| |
The meeting adjourned at 1:06.
Respectfully submitted,
_______________________
Barbara Tuck
Secretary
|